Thread: feedback please

Well im still new to photoshop, but i have been doing banners for some people.

Tell me what you think, any feedback good or bad.
and please rate them 1-10

This is my first ever banner(wasent for a person)
#1

Now, im doing stuff like these.

#2

#3

and my latest (not yet done)

#4

1) 9
2) -
3) 9
4) -

Mind if I won't comment ?

I like # 1 and # 3 don't know why, but I do. Possible reasons why I like 1 and 3 :

1. Simple but elegant looking.. (okay, it looks simple.. but when you look at it closely, the time and effort in producing the elegant output is not as simple as it looks)
2.-
3. Attracts attention. Green (neon?) color stands out and I like the font.
4.-

For being new to Photoshop, you are very good at what you're doing, I remember back in my old days (hey, I'm still in high school) there was nothing but MS Paint!

#1 Good color choices, the font is the biggest downfall here. 5
#2 Very good placement of the letters, love the animation. The stripes in the back give it a lovely touch. Never knew green and red could go so well with brown. 10
#3 Like the first one, it isn't a very good font combination, love the bevel though. 8
#4 I like the colors so far, just not sure if the font looks good, I don't see how paintball and spray paint go together, unless you are on the street doing it. 9

Originally Posted by Noobeedoo

1) 9
2) -
3) 9
4) -

Mind if I won't comment ?

I like # 1 and # 3 don't know why, but I do. Possible reasons why I like 1 and 3 :

1. Simple but elegant looking.. (okay, it looks simple.. but when you look at it closely, the time and effort in producing the elegant output is not as simple as it looks)
2.-
3. Attracts attention. Green (neon?) color stands out and I like the font.
4.-

Originally Posted by APocketFull

For being new to Photoshop, you are very good at what you're doing, I remember back in my old days (hey, I'm still in high school) there was nothing but MS Paint!

#1 Good color choices, the font is the biggest downfall here. 5
#2 Very good placement of the letters, love the animation. The stripes in the back give it a lovely touch. Never knew green and red could go so well with brown. 10
#3 Like the first one, it isn't a very good font combination, love the bevel though. 8
#4 I like the colors so far, just not sure if the font looks good, I don't see how paintball and spray paint go together, unless you are on the street doing it. 9

Im only 16, lol

Thanks for the comments, they made me feel good :scheesy:
any suggestions? :stongue:

Originally Posted by Ardit

Im only 16, lol

Thanks for the comments, they made me feel good :scheesy:
any suggestions? :stongue:

Looking good so far, maybe add to the background?

Better than I could do and I'm old!

Originally Posted by APocketFull

Looking good so far, maybe add to the background?

do you now of any tutorials that show you how to do those cool backgrounds?

Like this guys


Ardit added 0 Minutes and 54 Seconds later...

Originally Posted by GRIM

Better than I could do and I'm old!

lol, i doubt your that old.

Originally Posted by Ardit

do you now of any tutorials that show you how to do those cool backgrounds?

Like this guys


Ardit added 0 Minutes and 54 Seconds later...



lol, i doubt your that old.

No, there's some stock photos around like that though.

Originally Posted by APocketFull

No, there's some stock photos around like that though.

so people just use stock photos as textures?

Originally Posted by Ardit

so people just use stock photos as textures?

Yeah, at least I do sometimes.

i think that they are good i like the second one the most, 9-10 for that one.